Keep or Replace· by Livalyo
US
Menu

Choose for the long run

Smartphones

Compare smartphones using sourced facts to decide what to keep, repair or replace.

Catalog filters
Clear filters

5 of 5 · Smartphones

Sorted by release date: the catalogue places unknown dates last.

Generated, unofficial illustration of Google Pixel 9 Pro XL
Illustrative image

Google · 2024

Google Pixel 9 Pro XL

Announced support period
7 years

Declared resilience 8.50/10*

Provisional · Coverage 50 % · Method

Partial score: missing criteria: Declared battery cycles, Declared repeated drop resistance

Editorial repairability 10.00/10*

Provisional · Coverage 20 % · Method

Partial score: missing criteria: Disassembly depth, Repair documentation, Fastener removal

Customer feedback 9.25/10

Provisional · Coverage 100 % · Method

Keep · Medium confidence

View the analysis
Generated, unofficial illustration of Google Pixel 4a
Illustrative image

Google · 2020

Google Pixel 4a

Repairability index
6.3/10 · French repairability index

Editorial repairability 10.00/10*

Provisional · Coverage 20 % · Method

Partial score: missing criteria: Disassembly depth, Repair documentation, Fastener removal

≈ $150 · unverified (before sales tax)

Repair · High confidence

View the analysis
Generated, unofficial illustration of Google Pixel 10 Pro
Illustrative image

Google

Google Pixel 10 Pro

Announced support period
7 years
Repairability index
3.67/5 · EU 2023/1669
Charge cycles
1000 cycles

Declared resilience 8.10/10

Provisional · Coverage 100 % · Method

Editorial repairability 7.12/10

Provisional · Coverage 100 % · Method

Customer feedback 10.00/10

Provisional · Coverage 100 % · Method

Keep · Medium confidence

View the analysis
Generated, unofficial illustration of Google Pixel 5
Illustrative image

Google

Google Pixel 5

Repairability index
6.3/10 · French repairability index

Declared resilience 10.00/10*

Provisional · Coverage 25 % · Method

Partial score: missing criteria: Declared battery cycles, Declared repeated drop resistance, Declared support duration

≈ $350 · unverified (before sales tax)

Replace · Low confidence

View the analysis
Generated, unofficial illustration of Google Pixel 8
Illustrative image

Google

Google Pixel 8

Announced support period
7 years

Declared resilience 8.50/10*

Provisional · Coverage 50 % · Method

Partial score: missing criteria: Declared battery cycles, Declared repeated drop resistance

Customer feedback 8.00/10

Provisional · Coverage 100 % · Method

≈ $260 · unverified (before sales tax)

Keep · Low confidence

View the analysis